Electricity bills are rising, and the cost of building and maintaining the grid is a big reason. The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) introduced by a bipartisan group of senators in late September takes aim at that cost. Its transmission provisions would push utilities to adopt grid technologies that get more power through existing lines, make it easier to build long-distance transmission, and curb wasteful spending on local projects that utilities plan without competitive bidding.
After weighing input from many stakeholders, Senate negotiators released a manager’s amendment earlier this month that revises the transmission sections of the bill. Some of these revisions would spur competition and lower prices in the power sector; others would protect incumbent utilities at customers’ expense. Nonetheless, the bill remains a vast improvement over the status quo for electricity regulation.
The clearest improvement concerns advanced transmission technologies (ATTs), which let existing transmission lines and paths carry more electricity. Utilities have little reason to adopt ATTs on their own, since a regulated rate of return on what they build means an expensive new line earns them more than a cheaper upgrade that gets more out of existing lines. The original bill addressed this by requiring utilities to use these technologies and presumed the spending was prudent, which lets utilities charge customers for it without intense regulatory scrutiny. Yet it borrowed a broad, open-ended 2005 definition of ATTs, which ranged from underground cables to distributed generation. Many of these technologies do little to expand line capacity and some are costly, so customers could have been billed for expensive projects with a blank regulatory check.
The manager’s amendment narrows the list of ATTs to four technologies consistently recognized for their cost-effectiveness: dynamic line rating, advanced power flow control, topology optimization, and high-performance conductors. It also requires utilities to deploy these tools whenever the benefits exceed the costs, letting customers get more out of lines they’ve already paid for.
Negotiators also widened the bill’s oversight of local transmission, which utilities plan on their own, outside competitive regional processes. Because no competitor can bid on these projects, the bill allows state regulators to ask the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) to investigate whether their costs are justified. The original bill designated a project as local only if customers within a single utility’s territory paid its full cost. That excluded projects in regions like New England, where the costs of many utility-planned projects are spread across the region.
The new definition covers any project not selected in a regional plan, and it adds projects to replace aging equipment to the scope of review. Investigations would also proceed under the Federal Power Act’s authority over just and reasonable rates rather than its market manipulation authority, which lets FERC ask whether customers paid unreasonable costs rather than requiring proof of deception. Any penalties charged to utilities would flow back to the customers who bore the costs of wasteful project spending.
One change to the same provision, however, weakens this oversight. Only state utility commissions, rather than “states” broadly, could now refer a utility for investigation. State consumer advocates and attorneys general—often active watchdogs of utility spending—would lose the ability to bring cases to FERC.
The amendment also makes the bill’s data center cost protections more workable. The original text required utilities to charge each data center the full costs of new grid facilities built to serve it. In practice, that risked billing the first data center in an area for large upgrades that later customers would use for free. The revised bill instead requires data centers to pay a “reasonable assessment” of those costs, and it lets utilities spread them across data centers as a customer class rather than billing each one individually. It also applies the revised pricing to existing data center customers, not just new ones.
Yet the amendment left a flaw in this provision unaddressed: It sets billing requirements based on what a customer does, rather than the grid costs it causes. A factory drawing as much power as a data center, from the same part of the grid, would escape these new charges simply because it is not a data center. This runs counter to a basic principle of utility pricing, which holds that customers should pay based on the costs they impose, not their line of business. Tying new ratepayer protections to customers’ actual grid impact would protect households while treating all large power users alike.
The least favorable change concerns competition to build new regional lines. A right of first refusal (ROFR) lets the local utility claim a proposed project before any competitor can bid on it. The original bill banned these rights for regionally planned lines “notwithstanding” any existing FERC rule, overriding those rules. The amendment changes that to “except as otherwise provided” by rules in effect at enactment. That preserves exemptions FERC has already granted, such as for upgrades to existing facilities, so those projects can keep bypassing competition. FERC can’t create new ROFRs, but the current ones stay, and since the bill already requires the cost-effective upgrades they were meant to encourage, they now mainly shield incumbents from competitors.
Altogether, the manager’s amendment is a trade. A sharper definition of beneficial grid technologies, broader oversight of local projects, and more workable data center rules could benefit customers. Preserving incumbents’ existing rights of first refusal and limiting who can refer utility projects for investigation leave some savings on the table. Even with those flaws, BAAJA’s transmission provisions are an improvement over today’s rules and would leave households worried about rising electricity bills better off.




