Essay Energy

Why Permitting Reform Is So Hard

The debate over a bipartisan permitting bill reveals a fundamental tension between government accountability and the ability to build new infrastructure.

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA)—the most significant permitting legislation in decades—recently cleared a major procedural hurdle. The Senate’s cloture vote for the bill passed by a margin of 73–25, but Congress still has a way to go before there is agreement on which specific reforms are included in law. The political discourse around BAAJA has revealed deeper issues about why it can be so hard to pass durable energy and environmental policies.

Politicians often attribute opposition to their preferred policies to malice or ignorance, but the reality is that there is a tension between government accountability and government authority. Policies that make government decisions more accountable can also create opportunities for opponents to delay or obstruct those decisions. Permitting reform is ultimately about finding a balance between the two—because, ultimately, a permitting system that is beholden to political preferences is not sustainable.

BAAJA aims to address longstanding barriers to energy and infrastructure development. The bill’s bipartisan authors recognized that such projects are held back by a permitting system that is complicated, expensive, time-consuming, and subject to unpredictable political whims. That last item is particularly relevant for projects with a permitting timeframe that exceeds the duration of any one presidential administration. There’s even a word for this status quo of uncertainty—“Keystone-ization,” named after the Keystone XL pipeline which had its permit denied, approved, and then denied again. 

This cloud of uncertainty is not limited to fossil fuel projects. Offshore wind farms have  received stop work orders under the second Trump administration. Generally, clean energy projects are more likely to require complex environmental documentation. Transmission lines are frequently delayed by permitting constraints. In fact, renewable energy developers have noted that ordinances, zoning, grid interconnection, and community opposition are the leading causes of project cancellations, much more so than funding availability.

BAAJA, therefore, attempts to strike a balance between providing an easier, more predictable permitting process for developers and preserving environmental standards. Much ink has already been spilled explaining the functions of the bill, but, put simply, it aims to accelerate permitting by defining processes and strengthening existing “backstop” authority when states and localities fail to act, while maintaining substantive environmental protections. If BAAJA becomes law, states would no longer be able to delay transmission or pipeline projects indefinitely. Permit rejections would have to rest on a project’s failure to meet substantive environmental standards, and a much higher bar would be set for permits to be revoked and for plaintiffs to challenge a federal decision to issue a permit.

Several analysts have estimated that the legislation would, on net, reduce emissions associated with energy infrastructure. Resources for the Future estimated the bill would reduce cumulative power sector carbon dioxide emissions by 1.8 billion metric tons while saving $350 billion in electricity costs. The Climate Leadership Council estimated that power sector emissions would be reduced by 13.5 percent. And Columbia University’s Center on Global Energy Policy noted that the bill would improve energy security while likely producing a net reduction in emissions.

While a bill that improves economic outcomes by easing investment and improves environmental outcomes might appear to be a clear political winner, BAAJA has still faced considerable opposition. The Natural Resources Defense Council, Sierra Club, Earthjustice, Center for Biological Diversity, and other conservation organizations have opposed the bill despite analyses suggesting its potential environmental benefits. Concerns from environmental organizations largely focus on time limits and federal backstop authority for the currently open-ended consultations meant to preserve historic sites or endangered species habitat. Additionally, some groups have objected to the bill’s requirement that project challengers must have filed public comments describing their concerns before litigating a permit—a reform intended to give government agencies opportunities to remedy potential deficiencies before a permit is issued.

The core political problem is that people often want certain types of infrastructure to be permitted but not others. And politicians with authority over the permitting process are not immune to those preferences. Investors, however, cannot effectively allocate resources under conditions in which no one knows whether the government will allow a project to move forward or how long it will take to issue a permit.

BAAJA therefore seeks to restrict political power over permitting, even if that means enabling politically unpopular projects. Analyses of BAAJA’s effects largely note that polluting projects are a minority of expected new investment, and even those projects may displace more polluting alternatives. This is why even though BAAJA is expected to make it easier to permit fossil fuel projects, its overall effect on emissions is expected to be positive.

Another reason some have opposed the bill is because it limits the ability of litigants to delay projects. While many groups point out that litigation can improve government accountability, the same processes create opportunities to simply delay infrastructure buildout. 

Litigation is not only an issue for fossil fuels. A recent analysis of litigation against renewable energy projects found that “regional or local environmental groups and Tribal representatives were the largest source of court challenges to solar and wind projects.” That is consistent with other studies, such as another analysis of litigation from 2001–2013 which found that 59 percent of plaintiffs were public-interest groups. Another analysis of appeals cases from 2013–2022 found that 72 percent of challenges were from nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), with a small number accounting for the lion’s share of the challenges. The government wins most of these cases, suggesting that these challenges are unlikely to result in any meaningful improvements to permit quality.

For organizations that believe the way to preserve the environment is by making it hard to build infrastructure they view as environmentally destructive, current laws offers ample opportunity to interfere with permits. As a result, organizations that rely on litigation to oppose projects they disfavor have an incentive to oppose reforms that would limit their ability to do so, even if they may favor advancing some infrastructure they view as beneficial.

Ultimately, this is why permitting reform is such a political bear. Americans generally have a favorable view of the laws designed to encourage accountability in the permitting process. At the same time, Americans are also fed up with the status quo that enshrines a “vetocracy” in which numerous parties have the power to delay or block development. Polling shows that 66 percent of Americans support BAAJA even after hearing arguments against it. Given affordability concerns held by many Americans, it is hard to defend the notion that well-resourced organizations should be advantaged in using the law to stymie development. BAAJA aims to strike a balance that safeguards public benefits while setting a higher bar for opposition to new projects.

Congress still has a long way to go on a final permitting reform deal; some senators who voted yes on cloture have said they would ultimately oppose the bill without additional changes. But broadly speaking, many politicians seem to understand that the current system creates undue burdens on new infrastructure that could help address energy affordability concerns, and that reforms are needed to unlock the investments that can make America’s economy both cleaner and more prosperous.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of C3 Journal.

About the author

Philip Rossetti

Lighthouse Energy Institute

Philip Rossetti is the vice president of environment, innovation, and transportation at the Lighthouse Energy Institute. He was previously a senior fellow at the R Street Institute, where he led energy innovation, energy security, climate, and environmental policy work. Before joining R Street, Philip was a fellow in the U.S. House of Representatives working with the minority staff of the Select Committee on the Climate Crisis. In this position, he supported congressional staff through policy and data analysis to brief legislators and helped fulfill the committee’s mandate to evaluate federal climate policy. Prior to that, he was the director of energy policy at the American Action Forum, a center-right economically focused think tank.

Philip received an M.A. in international relations and diplomacy from the Whitehead School of Diplomacy at Seton Hall University. He also received a B.A. in political science from the University of New Mexico, where he was also a national security studies scholar.

More from this writer →

Introducing C3 Journal

A new Journal. A bigger conversation.

C3 News Mag is now C3 Journal—a complete rethink of what an energy and environmental publication can be. Original essays. Leading contributors. The issues that matter, examined by some of America’s best policy minds. Built for the people making consequential decisions about energy, the environment, and our shared future.

C3 News Mag is now C3 Journal. A new home for original essays, leading policy minds, and the ideas shaping energy and the environment.

Get Field Notes, the C3 Journal newsletter.