America has a big appetite for seafood—and a remarkable reluctance to let its own farmers supply it.
The United States recorded a $20.7 billion seafood trade deficit in 2025, importing nearly five times as much seafood by value as it exported. Imports help meet consumer demand, but that enormous market also represents an opportunity for America’s farmers, entrepreneurs, and coastal communities. We have the customers and scientific expertise. What we lack is a policy environment that allows domestic aquaculture to compete.
The rest of the world has recognized the opportunity. Aquaculture now provides more than half of the world’s aquatic animal production, producing a record 100 million metric tons in 2024. Nearly all of the growth in aquatic production since the late 1980s has come from farming, while wild catches have largely plateaued. Wild fisheries remain essential, but fishing alone cannot deliver unlimited growth from a biologically limited resource.
American aquaculture, meanwhile, is barely advancing. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s latest census showed inflation-adjusted aquaculture sales increased just 3.8 percent between 2018 and 2023 (. Globally, production of farmed aquatic animals expanded by an average of 4.9 percent annually between 2000 and 2024 (FAO, 2026) . Five years of such modest growth should concern anyone interested in domestic food production, economic opportunity, or American competitiveness.
The Trump administration has recognized the opportunity to strengthen domestic seafood production. But so far, its efforts have focused on supporting commercial fishermen rather than expanding aquaculture. Meanwhile, domestic fish farmers continue to face significant regulatory and financial obstacles. Washington should give aquaculture a more prominent place in its seafood strategy, starting with reforms that make it easier for American producers to compete.
The case for expanding seafood production extends beyond economics. Seafood, including from aquaculture, provides valuable protein, omega 3 fats, and micronutrients. Research comparing nutrition and climate impacts found that seafood, averaged across the species studied, offered greater nutrient density than beef, pork, or chicken, and with lower greenhouse gas emissions than beef or pork.
Aquaculture also offers opportunities to grow food with relatively little land and freshwater. Farmed shellfish require no manufactured feed; marine farming can expand without converting additional pasture or cropland. Environmental performance varies by species, feed, and energy source, but those differences are reasons to encourage better technologies and practices. They should not become excuses to obstruct the entire industry.
President Donald Trump recognized this opportunity in an April 2025 executive order on “Restoring American Seafood Competitiveness,” which explicitly includes aquaculture and directs the development of a strategy supporting American fishery and aquaculture production, marketing, sales, and exports. Delivering that vision requires helping farmers grow more seafood. Yet the Agriculture Department’s new Office of Seafood has concentrated its public-facing work on bringing wild fishermen into agricultural programs, rather than addressing the obstacles facing fish farmers.
At its launch, the Agriculture Department emphasized the importance of integrating fishermen into its services. The office subsequently established a partnership with the University of Maine’s Local Catch Network to conduct outreach, webinars, and gather industry input on federal seafood programs. Although the announcement mentions aquaculture, its activities emphasize harvesters, processors, distributors, and fishing communities. Director Michael Illenberg described the partnership as a response to “hundreds of direct inquiries” from seafood harvesters seeking access to the department’s programs and marketing support.
These are concrete services for fishing businesses. But where is the comparable, measurable agenda addressing aquatic farmers’ financing, insurance, regulatory uncertainty, and market barriers?


The administration’s October seafood announcement reinforced the imbalance. Its fact sheet repeatedly emphasized fishermen and promoted a voluntary “U.S. Caught Seafood” label, without mentioning aquaculture. The broader strategy does include aquaculture, but its public presentation leaves fish farmers struggling for recognition within an initiative that explicitly encompasses their industry.
Meanwhile, fish farmers face several interconnected obstacles. Lenders struggle to value aquatic livestock and specialized equipment, insurance options are limited, and permitting uncertainty and prolonged litigation undermine investment. Public misconceptions about the industry also discourage customers and policymakers.
Congress could now entrench the imbalance. Section 5216 of the Senate Farm Bill proposal would extend agricultural operating-loan eligibility to commercial fishing, including acquiring, operating, and maintaining fishing vessels. Expanding access without resolving existing farmers’ needs risks spreading finite resources more thinly.
The National Aquaculture Association has explicitly urged lawmakers to reject that provision, arguing that agricultural loans are designed to support producers who cultivate and manage crops they own, not businesses that harvest wild public resources. The association warns that adding fishing businesses could increase application backlogs, require unfamiliar collateral and risk assessments, and reduce funds available to farmers already struggling to secure capital. The association instead recommends supporting commercial fisheries through the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), which is housed within the Commerce Department, with dedicated funding and relevant expertise.
The Florida Farm Bureau resolution goes further. It opposes redefining agriculture to include wild-capture fishermen and vessels, integrating commercial fishing into agricultural programs, and the Office of Seafood’s current structure. It calls for wild fisheries to remain under NOAA’s expertise and supports a Department of Agriculture office aligned with aquaculture production, marketing, sales, and exports.
These objections deserve an answer before Congress makes the office’s direction permanent. Farmers are asking why the Agriculture Department is expanding its constituency before adequately serving producers already within its agricultural mission.
The department should identify and correct aquaculture eligibility gaps, improve how existing financing and risk-management programs accommodate aquatic crops, and educate staff across agencies. Regulators should coordinate reviews, eliminate duplication, and provide dependable timelines.
The government need not guarantee a farm’s success. It should provide clear rules and administer them competently, allowing entrepreneurs to invest, innovate, and compete.
America needs both fishermen and fish farmers. But growing our seafood supply requires growing seafood, and that means expanding domestic aquaculture. The president’s order recognizes that reality. The Department of Agriculture—and the next Farm Bill—should respond accordingly.




