Essay Energy

President Trump Should Rethink a Diesel Export Ban

With diesel at record highs, there is a strong political temptation to look for levers to bring prices down. Last week, Politico reported that the administration was drafting a 90-day ban on diesel exports. Pushback from officials and industry groups has since slowed the proposal, but President Trump says he is still considering it.

Given diesel’s importance to farming and freight, and its political significance ahead of the midterm elections, frustration with high prices is understandable. But a ban is misguided. At best it would provide temporary relief, and it would likely create broader market distortions that undermine the very economic and political goals it is meant to serve. That is why C3 Solutions joined a coalition letter last week urging the president to reject the idea.

Diesel is a globally traded commodity, and its price reflects world supply and demand. Today’s high prices are largely the result of disruptions to oil flowing through the Strait of Hormuz amid ongoing tensions with Iran, along with Ukrainian strikes on Russian refineries. The United States is the world’s largest diesel exporter, and the logic of a ban is to trap that fuel at home, creating a domestic glut that pushes prices down.

But the evidence suggests the effect would be modest, uneven, and temporary. Goldman Sachs estimates that a ban could cut diesel prices by about 25 cents a gallon each week, but only as long as refiners have room to store the fuel they can no longer sell abroad. Once storage fills, refiners would have to cut output. Because diesel and gasoline are refined from the same crude oil, that would mean less gasoline too, pushing already high gasoline prices up 30 cents a gallon per additional week of the ban.

The effects would also be uneven, because parts of the country rely on imported fuel. New England, for example, lacks the pipeline capacity to receive enough fuel from Gulf Coast refineries, and the limited number of Jones Act–compliant tankers can’t make up the difference. Pulling U.S. supply off the world market would raise global prices, and with them prices in import-dependent regions.

Over the longer term, the bigger damage is the precedent such a ban sets. Access to global markets means supply disruptions in one place can be at least partly offset by production elsewhere, which benefits domestic industry and makes supply chains more stable worldwide. Intervening to chase short-term price relief ultimately hurts American industry and consumers. And once the government shows it is willing to wall off exports when prices become politically inconvenient, investors in refining capacity have a new policy risk to price in. An energy dominance agenda requires a strong domestic industry and the free flow of American energy to the world.

Accepting that there is no quick fix for high energy prices is a tough pill for policymakers to swallow. Their best option is to focus on deeper, structural reforms. The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, introduced in the Senate this week, would speed up permitting and limit the lawsuits that delay energy infrastructure of all kinds. Repealing restrictions like the Jones Act would make it easier to move fuel from where it is refined to the parts of the country that need it.

In the near term, the surest path to lower energy prices is through diplomacy and open markets. From diesel to crude oil to the mineral inputs that modern energy and manufacturing depend on, prices are high because of conflict and trade barriers. A durable end to the Iran war, rolling back U.S.-China export controls, and lowering trade barriers with allied suppliers are all moves that would contribute to more stable supply chains and lower prices for American manufacturers and consumers.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of C3 Journal.

About the author

David Kemp

C3 Solutions

David Kemp is the Vice President of Policy at C3 Solutions, where he oversees and writes about energy and climate policy. His work examines how public policy and market incentives shape energy and environmental outcomes.

More from this writer →

Introducing C3 Journal

A new Journal. A bigger conversation.

C3 News Mag is now C3 Journal—a complete rethink of what an energy and environmental publication can be. Original essays. Leading contributors. The issues that matter, examined by some of America’s best policy minds. Built for the people making consequential decisions about energy, the environment, and our shared future.

C3 News Mag is now C3 Journal. A new home for original essays, leading policy minds, and the ideas shaping energy and the environment.

Get Field Notes, the C3 Journal newsletter.